Skip to content
search-engine-optimizedby Netsolution

Customer reviews: what the rules allow

Soliciting reviews is allowed, on one condition written in plain words: without offering anything in return, and for genuine experiences. Forbidden by name are paid reviews, reviews posted from several accounts at one person's request, and those arising from a conflict of interest.

What does the rule say precisely, on the permitted side?

Let us start with the permission, because that is what people are looking for and it is almost always misreported.

A business is allowed to solicit or encourage the posting of content representing a genuine experience, without offering anything in return.

officialSource : Maps User Generated Content Policy, “Prohibited & restricted content”

Two conditions, and only two: the experience has to be genuine, and there is nothing offered in return. Asking a satisfied customer for a review is therefore not a grey area, it is an explicitly permitted practice. What tips the request into the forbidden is not the asking — it is what you put opposite it.

What is forbidden, by name?

A review or rating must reflect a genuine experience with the business, and be authentic and unbiased; content not based on a genuine experience is forbidden.

officialSource : Maps User Generated Content Policy, “Prohibited & restricted content”

The word “unbiased” deserves attention, because it opens onto the most common case in small organisations:

Content arising from a conflict of interest is forbidden, which covers among other things current or past employment, a contractual relationship, a family tie or a competitor's position.

officialSource : Maps User Generated Content Policy, “Prohibited & restricted content”

Employees, former employees, contractors, family, competitors: the list is explicit. Yet that is exactly the first circle a business turns to at launch, often in good faith and without imagining it is entering a forbidden category.

Soliciting reviews systematically, with nothing offered in return

hypothesis

Effort
moderate
Time to effect
weeks
Risk
none
Durability
lasting

Update of 11 August 2026

The documentation on review snippets received an additional instruction on 24 July 2026: it forbids by name fake reviews and undisclosed incentivised reviews, and announces a possible manual action. The line drawn therefore does not separate the paid review from the spontaneous one but the declared inducement from the concealed one. The full record, with the exact quotations and the widely ignored rule that keeps reviews controlled by the rated entity out of the stars, is in the monitoring log.

A brown steel municipal suggestion box, cut out with a dandelion and a cockerel, carrying the words “Vos suggestions citoyennes” and a single slot.
One slot, no filter, and nobody to ask permission from before writing. That is a shopkeeper's position facing reviews: you can ask for the gesture, you do not hold the hand that writes.Chabe01 — CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons, relevé le

What influence do reviews really have?

Prominence — how well known a business is — is among the three published local ranking factors, alongside relevance and distance.

officialSource : Google Business Profile, “Tips to improve your local ranking on Google”

That is everything published, and it is worth sticking to. Prominence is a factor; reviews visibly take part in what “being known” means. But no source says how they contribute, in what proportion, or whether a threshold of count or rating exists.

Any service announcing that a certain number of reviews or a certain average crosses a step is therefore advancing a figure with no origin. It is not necessarily false, it is unverifiable — and on this site, the difference between the two is the whole subject.

How do you ask, then?

Three principles are enough, and they follow directly from the text of the rule.

Ask everybody, not only the happy ones. Soliciting only the customers you expect a good review from produces a set that does not reflect the genuine experience, which the rule requires elsewhere. It is also what makes a perfect average suspect to read.

Offer nothing, including token gestures. A coffee, a discount, an entry into a draw: the rule names free goods and services, not only money.

Answer negative reviews rather than trying to make them disappear. A factual reply is read by the next customers, and it stays possible when removal does not. Offering compensation in exchange for removal is precisely forbidden.

What does not work, or no longer works

Offer ten percent off to every customer who leaves a five-star review, have a few posted by your team to get started, and offer unhappy customers a goodwill gesture so they take their review down.

All three instructions are forbidden by name in the same rule: an inducement for a review, the conflict of interest covering employee reviews, and encouraging the removal of a negative review. None of them is a grey area.

One last habit to revisit: treating the average rating as the goal. An average is built out of experiences, not out of a campaign; and a perfect score obtained on a selected set mostly tells you about the selection. This site publishes no five-star rating for the tools it describes, for a related reason: a single figure hides the reasoning it claims to summarise.

Sources

  1. Prohibited & restricted content — Maps User Generated Content Policy — Googleaccessed on
  2. Tips to improve your local ranking on Google — Google Business Profileaccessed on
  3. Guidelines for representing your business on Google — Google Business Profileaccessed on
  4. Manual actions report — Google Search Consoleaccessed on

Block revalidated on

Frequently asked questions

Can you ask your customers for a review?
Yes, and it is written explicitly in the rule: soliciting or encouraging the posting of content representing a genuine experience is allowed, on condition that nothing is offered in return. The request is therefore perfectly legitimate; it is the exchange that is not.
Is a prize draw or a discount for a review permitted?
No. The rule names payment, discounts and free goods or services offered in exchange for a review, for changing it or for removing a negative one. A prize draw conditional on posting falls under that description.
Can you ask your employees to leave a review?
No. Content arising from a conflict of interest is forbidden, and the rule names current or past employment, contractual relationships and family ties. Those reviews are also the easiest to spot, which makes the risk worse.
Do reviews influence local ranking?
Prominence is one of the three published factors, but no source details how reviews contribute to it, in what proportion, or whether a threshold exists. Any numbered claim on this point is a hypothesis, including when it is delivered confidently.