Stars in the results
Review markup only earns stars under precise conditions: the rating must be visible on the page, must concern an identified item, and must not be aggregated from other sites. Above all, an entity that controls the reviews about itself is not eligible for that display.
The rule behind most of the disappointment
The stars shown beside a result are one of the few visual elements a publisher can hope to earn through markup. It is also the subject where the gap is widest between what sits on pages and what is actually eligible.
Where the entity being reviewed controls the reviews about itself, its pages using local business or any other organization markup are ineligible for the star review feature; the example given is a review about entity A placed on entity A's own website, directly or through an embedded third-party widget.
officialSource : Google Search Central, “Review snippet structured data”
That sentence eliminates at a stroke a large share of the markup installed across the web: a business that collects and displays the reviews about itself controls those reviews, and its pages are therefore ineligible for the star display. The rule does not say those reviews are false; it says that whoever hosts them is also the party they judge.
Embedding an external review widget on your own pages changes nothing about eligibility: the documentation names that arrangement explicitly, so the technical origin of the display does not move the question of who controls the reviews.
hypothesis
The status is that of a reading, but it rests on an explicit example: the documentation names the embedded third-party widget alongside markup written directly. We conclude that the technical origin of the display does not move the question.
Install our verified reviews widget and show your stars in Google within fifteen days, on every service page.
The conditions nobody reads
The marked-up review content must be readily available to users from the marked-up page: they must be able to see the review text and its rating, and to see the aggregate rating if one is declared.
officialSource : Google Search Central, “Review snippet structured data”
The principle matches all structured data: what is declared must be seen. An aggregate rating computed behind the scenes and never displayed does not exist for the reader, and the markup then stops describing the page and starts supplementing it.
A review must concern a specific item rather than a category or a list of items, and must refer clearly to that item by nesting or through the property provided for it.
officialSource : Google Search Central, “Review snippet structured data”
That requirement rules out a frequent arrangement: the company’s overall satisfaction score, shown on every product page. It does not concern the product described, so it does not describe the item on the page.
The documentation asks that reviews or ratings from other websites not be aggregated, and that several individual reviews be accompanied by an aggregate rating of those reviews.
officialSource : Google Search Central, “Review snippet structured data”
Reviews obtained in exchange for something
Excluded are reviews not based on a genuine experience of the product or service, and reviews written in exchange for a benefit — money, discounts, vouchers, free products — that do not clearly and prominently disclose the incentive.
officialSource : Google Search Central, “Review snippet structured data”
Two categories are named together, and they are worth separating. The first has no remedy: a review based on no genuine experience has no place, however it is presented. The second does, and it fits in one line — state clearly and prominently what was given in exchange.
Breaching these guidelines may lead to a manual action against the site, with the possibility of requesting reconsideration once the problem is remedied.
officialSource : Google Search Central, “Review snippet structured data”
Marking up reviews after checking the reviewed entity's eligibility
hypothesis
- Effort
- moderate
- Time to effect
- weeks
- Risk
- notable
- Durability
- lasting
The effort is moderate, the markup being simple. The delay follows crawling. The risk is the highest of any card on this site, and deliberately so: this is one of the rare subjects where an incorrect implementation exposes you to a manual action rather than to a mere absence of effect. Durability is medium, the eligibility rules for this display having changed before.
What does not work, or no longer works
Showing your own customer reviews on your own pages and expecting stars. The documentation excludes that case explicitly, embedded widget included.
Then reusing the score earned on a review platform. Aggregating from other websites is explicitly advised against.
Finally, putting a company-wide rating on product pages. The review must concern the item on the page, not the house that sells it.
Sources
- Review snippet structured data — Google Search Centralaccessed on
- Google Search spam policies — Google Search Centralaccessed on
Block revalidated on
Frequently asked questions
- Why are my stars missing when the markup validates?
- The commonest cause is not technical: if the entity being reviewed controls the reviews about itself, its pages are ineligible for that display. A site showing its own customer reviews on its own pages fits that description, embedded third-party widget included.
- Does an external review widget change anything?
- The documentation names that case explicitly: a review about an entity placed on that entity's own site, directly or through an embedded third-party widget. The technical origin of the display therefore does not move the question, which is about control of the reviews rather than how they are embedded.
- Can you reuse ratings from a review platform?
- No. The documentation asks that reviews or ratings from other websites not be aggregated. A rating shown on a page must match what that page collects and displays, and the aggregate must summarise the individual reviews present, not those from elsewhere.
- Must incentivised reviews be disclosed?
- What matters is that the incentive be disclosed clearly and prominently. Failing that, the review falls into the undisclosed incentivised category, excluded on the same footing as reviews not based on any genuine experience of the product or service.
- What does a site risk by ignoring these rules?
- The documentation puts it plainly: a manual action may be taken against the site. It appears in the console with its reason, and reconsideration can be requested once the problem is fixed. That is a different mechanism from simply not being eligible for the display.