Link buying, PBNs and penalties: what is documented
The published rules name payment for links intended to influence ranking. A decision taken on those grounds is a manual action: it comes from a human reviewer, it is notified in Search Console, and it carries a stated reason. Almost everything else said about penalties is unverifiable.
Why does this page exist?
Because this is the worst documented subject in search and the most abundantly commented on. You find scales of penalty duration, tolerance thresholds, ratios of links not to exceed: none of those figures has a source. This page therefore separates what is written in a public document from what belongs to storytelling.
What exactly do the published rules name?
Exchanging money for links, or for posts containing links, intended to influence ranking is among the practices Google calls link spam.
officialSource : Google Search Central, spam policies for Google web search
The criterion is payment intended to influence ranking. Neither the commercial relationship in itself, nor advertising, nor partnership: the intention of weighing on the ranking, and the concealment that goes with it. The rest of the same source confirms it from the other side:
It is not a breach to have such links as long as they are qualified by an attribute declaring them sponsored or nofollow.
officialSource : Google Search Central, spam policies for Google web search
That is why a network of sites created to host unqualified editorial links falls under the description, while a declared ad slot does not. The difference is not one of degree, it is one of nature: one declares what it is, the other depends on not being recognised.
Buying unqualified editorial links
officialGoogle Search Central, spam policies for Google web search
not advised
- Effort
- low
- Time to effect
- weeks
- Risk
- high
- Durability
- short-lived
The durability axis is at its minimum, and that is the strongest argument against the practice — stronger than the risk, which one can always talk oneself into accepting. A bought link stops existing the day you stop paying, or the day the host site disappears. The spending is therefore recurring for an asset that does not accumulate.

Who decides a manual action, and how do you know?
This is the most useful point in the guide, and it is unusually precise:
A manual action is taken when a human reviewer has determined that pages on the site do not comply with the anti-spam rules.
officialSource : Google Search Console, “Manual actions report”
A human reviewer. Three consequences follow, and they contradict most of what gets said. The decision is not a threshold crossed. It is notified, because it has an author. And it carries a named reason, which makes correction possible instead of leaving you to guess.
The report states whether a manual action applies to the site and on what grounds, including unnatural, artificial, deceptive or manipulative links pointing at it.
officialSource : Google Search Console, “Manual actions report”
Most manual actions result in pages ranking lower, or being removed from the search results.
officialSource : Google Search Console, “Manual actions report”
“Ranking lower, or removed”: two outcomes of very different severity, and nothing lets you predict which applies. Above all, keep the practical corollary of all this: if the report is empty, there is no manual action. A traffic drop with nothing in that report has another explanation — a change in demand, new competition, a change to the site, or the variations the documentation describes as spontaneous.
What nobody can tell you
No public source describes a delay, a scale or a duration for these decisions: the numbered accounts circulating on the subject are reconstructions from individual cases.
hypothesis
It is worth measuring the extent of that ignorance, because it is the opposite of what the market implies. No public source says how long a decision stays in force, what exactly has to be fixed for it to be lifted, from what volume of links a reason is made out, nor what proportion of qualified links would be “normal”.
Any discourse advancing those figures built them from individual cases reported by their own victims — with no access to the exact reason, nor to the list of corrections actually made, nor to what would have happened without them. Those are testimonies, not measurements, and this site will treat them as such the day it publishes any.
What do you do if a manual action is notified?
Three steps, in this order, and none of them is a shortcut.
Read the exact reason, which appears in the report. It is the only reliable information available, and it bounds the work: a reason bearing on inbound links calls for different gestures from a reason bearing on content.
Fix it for real, which means removing what is at issue rather than hiding it. On links, the normal route is removal at the source; disavowal only comes in for what cannot be removed, and its own instructions warn that it can do harm if used badly.
Request a review, which only makes sense after the fix. It is precisely because a human took the decision that a human can reconsider it.
What does not work, or no longer works
After a Google penalty, allow three to six months of clean-up, disavow every link under DR 20, and republish your content on a new domain to start fresh.
One last belief deserves naming, because it serves as a sales argument: the idea that a penalty is inevitable and widespread, so everyone runs the risk anyway. The manual actions report says exactly the opposite for most sites: it is empty. What explains the majority of poor performance is not a penalty, it is the absence of a reason to be chosen — a less spectacular subject, and one where there is far more to do.
Sources
- Spam policies for Google web search — Google Search Centralaccessed on
- Manual actions report — Google Search Consoleaccessed on
- Disavow links to your site — Google Search Consoleaccessed on
- Qualify your outbound links to Google — Google Search Centralaccessed on
Block revalidated on
Frequently asked questions
- How do you know whether your site has been penalised?
- Through the manual actions report, which states explicitly that a decision exists and on what grounds. It is the only source that talks about your site in particular. A traffic drop with nothing in that report has other explanations, often far more ordinary ones.
- Is a manual action automatic?
- No, and that is its very definition: it is taken when a human reviewer has found a breach of the published rules. That human involvement explains why these decisions are notified with their reason, and why a review can be requested once the problem is fixed.
- How long does a penalty last?
- No duration is published, and no scale either. The numbered accounts in circulation come from individual cases reported by their own victims, with no way of checking the exact reason recorded nor the corrections that were actually made.
- Can a competitor get my site penalised with bad links?
- Nothing public describes that scenario as workable, and the documentation presents disavowal as a rarely needed tool. The fear is real and widespread; watching for it through the manual actions report costs less than acting on a supposition.