Link analysis
A link analysis tool crawls the web with its own robot and shows you the links it found pointing at a site. It sees neither every link nor the ones the engine keeps: its figures serve to compare orders of magnitude, never to establish an inventory.
What does a link analysis tool show?
The links it found. The phrasing is pedantic and it is nonetheless the whole subject: these tools do not consult an engine’s index, they crawl the web themselves and keep their findings in an index of their own.
Every tool builds its own link index with its own robot: counting gaps between two tools measure their respective coverage, not the reality of the profile.
hypothesis
That constraint is not a manufacturing defect, it is the condition of the exercise, and it holds for any robot including the engine’s:
A crawler does not download every page it discovers: some are disallowed by the site, others require authentication.
officialSource : Google Search Central, “In-depth guide to how Google Search works”
No total displayed by one of these tools is therefore an inventory. It is a coverage reading, and its value is comparative: between two sites observed by the same tool, the gap means something. Between two tools, it means nothing at all.
What are authority scores worth?
The authority scores these tools display are proprietary indicators, calculated by unpublished methods, which no engine recognises or uses.
hypothesis
Those scores are useful inside one tool, as an internal ranking consistent with itself. They become misleading as soon as they are quoted as properties of the site: no engine publishes an equivalent, none commits to any correspondence, and a figure with two decimals gives an estimate the appearance of a measurement. It is the same illusion as search volumes, transposed to links.
Analysing your link profile to understand who talks about you
hypothesis
- Effort
- moderate
- Time to effect
- weeks
- Risk
- none
- Durability
- seasonal
What useful work can be done with this category?
Three things, and none of them needs a complete inventory.
Seeing who already talks about you, which is often a surprise and sometimes a commercial lead. Looking at which content in a sector attracts links without asking, which tells you what deserves writing. Spotting a plain anomaly, of the mass-appearance-from-unrelated-sites kind.
What these tools do not allow, on the other hand, is deciding that a link is harmful. The list is incomplete by construction, the scores are proprietary, and removing links that were causing no problem is an irreversible operation carried out on hints.
Where is the line, in this category?
It is clear, it is documented, and this category runs closer to it than the other three.
What replaces a link analysis tool?
Search Console reports the links the engine has associated with your site, which no third-party tool can know. Its view is partial and it is the only one coming from the right source. To observe a competitor, on the other hand, there is no serious free solution: it is the one need in this category that genuinely justifies spending.
What does not work, or no longer works
Your authority score is 34: buy ten high-score links to get ahead of your competitors, or disavow the toxic links our tool detected.
Two entries are published here: Majestic, and Babbar, a French vendor whose indicators take account of the subject of the linked pages and not only of their number. No open substitute is set against them — not for want of looking, but because none exists. What you pay for in a link tool is not the software: it is an index built by a robot crawling the web permanently, over years. An open project can write the same software; it cannot equip itself with the same inventory. The page open source tools, in French, develops that point, which holds for the suites too.
The criteria that will decide the rest of this category are on the directory index. No link marketplace will ever appear there, affiliated or not.
Sources
- Spam policies for Google web search — Google Search Centralaccessed on
- In-depth guide to how Google Search works — Google Search Centralaccessed on
- SEO Starter Guide: The Basics — Google Search Centralaccessed on
Block revalidated on
Entries in this category
Frequently asked questions
- Why do two tools not count the same links?
- Because each crawls the web with its own robot and keeps what it found in its own index. The gap between two totals measures the difference in coverage between two crawls, not the reality of a site's link profile.
- Are these tools' authority scores recognised by search engines?
- No. They are proprietary indicators, useful for comparing two domains within one tool, and meaningless outside it. No engine publishes an equivalent or relies on those values, however precisely they are displayed.
- What is this category of tools really for?
- Three honest things: seeing who already talks about you, understanding which content in a sector attracts links spontaneously, and spotting an obvious attack. None of the three needs a complete inventory, which is just as well since one is impossible.
- Should you disavow the poor-quality links these tools find?
- That is a heavy decision to take on the basis of an incomplete list and proprietary scores. Absent an explicit signal in Search Console, caution means doing nothing rather than removing links that were causing no problem.